By Innocent Anaba
Mr Israel Mbaebie:
While Section 41 (1) of the 1999 Constitution of Nigeria (as amended) guarantees every Nigerian the freedom of movement; section 41 (2) (a) however provides a caveat to the effect that the Federal Government may stop anyone from leaving Nigeria if he had committed a crime or is REASONABLY SUSPECTED to have committed a crime.
On the other hand, Section 36 (5) of the same constitution provides for the presumption of innocence for anyone CHARGED with any criminal offence.
Now, if we juxtapose the above cited constitutional provisions vis-à-vis the present ban by the Federal Government; two salient questions need be answered viz;
- Have those Nigerians been indicted for any criminal offence to warrant the issuance of that order? The wording of the “Executive Order” has it that the individuals involved are being “INVESTIGATED”.
In my view, investigating someone does not pass the “REASONABILITY TEST” as as required by the constitution as to warrant the issuance of that order. Merely investigating a person is and cannot be enough ground to infringe on his/her constitutional fundamental human rights. After all, he is deemed innocent until proven otherwise
- What could be done in the light of the subsisting court judgment?
The persons involved/affected should challenge the judgment on appeal. I’m convinced the order would be vacated on appeal
Wahab Shittu, Senior Law Lecturer, University of Lagos:
The executive order made by the president which the court has now affirmed is now part of our law. To the extent that the court has affirmed executive order 6 as part of our law, what the president is doing, is consistent with the rule of law. It would have been different if the order was declared unconstitutional, then we would have said that what the president is doing now is in violation of the law. But the Executive order having been upheld by the court, the president is right to proceed under that order to make this travel ban. Once the president is operating under executive order 6, nobody can accuse the president of violating the rule of law.
Monday Ubani, ex- 2nd Vice President, NBA:
I know that the issue of restriction of an individual’s movement is a constitutional issue. Unless there is a validly made order by the court, I don’t think the president has the power to restrict the movement of an individual. I don’t think the president’s executive order entails restriction movement of individuals. Anyone who feels the president has by this latest travel ban has infringed on his or her right to movement, has the right to approach the court.
I must add that it is not right for the president to create a state of fear with this travel ban. We are in a democracy, we don’t want a situation where people will be persecuted and not properly prosecuted through the law court. Those who have stolen the nations money should be duly and lawfully prosecuted. I am afraid to say that I don’t believe the president executive has gotten, has also extended his power to restrict people movement.
Joseph Otteh, Executive Director, Access to Justice:
I think the federal government is over reaching its constitutional powers by placing that travel ban. The right to travel is a fundamental right and the constitution has listed instances where that right can be limited or restricted.
The making of executive order is not among those instances that gives government right to restrict people’s movement.
I think the federal government has overreached what the judgment it is claiming to have on that executive order. The government has over extended that judgment. That judgment certainly does not give FG power to violate the right of any individual. This is just a power grab. Imagine sought of situations can could happen if government begins to make executive orders like this. The danger is so horrendous and I don’t think an court will uphold this.
About Article Author
Latest Nigeria News
- Senate confirms Buhari’s nominees
- CAC registers 39,074 new business names in two months under N5,000 fees strategy
- Crisis rocks Sanwo-Olu’s campaign organization
- APC questions Okorocha, six others over anti-party activities
- Buhari defends Governor Ganduje on $5m bribe video at Town-hall Interactive Programme
- Uproars over directive to freeze CJN Onnoghen’s accounts
- PDP says Osinbajo lied
- How CUPP leaked plot to freeze Onnoghen’s accounts
- Agbakoba files suit asking Court to stop Onnoghen’s arraignment
- Even at expense of my life, I’ll privatize NNPC, says Atiku
- North ready to embrace restructuring, says el-Rufai
- Here's Man Who R*ped 78yrs Old Woman In Lagos... He has been dragged to court
- Buhari Raises Alarm: Boko Haram Sponsored By Forces Outside Nigeria
- IGP Adamu Talks Tough, Blames Poor Leadership For Problems In Nigeria Police
- Nigeria’s inflation rate shots up in December – NBS
- Theresa May survives No Confidence Vote
- Rich Kidnapper Evans Makes More Revelations
- I Feel Sad Over CJN Onnoghen's Trial – Osinbajo
- CCTV Captures The Shocking Moment Thief Scaled Fence Into A House In Lagos
- PHOTO: Atiku Bows As He Meets Ooni Of Ife
- MC Oluomo Discharged From Lagos Hospital (Photos)
- Falana Opens Up: Dangerous Precedents Being Set In CJN Case
- So Sad! Husband, Wife & Their Son Die In Terrible Accident
- Reactions Trailing FG's Latest Action Against CJN Onnoghen
- I Will Privatize NNPC, It's A Mafia Organization – Atiku
- New IGP Gives First Order To All Police Officers
- Good Doctor Hurries To Help Victims Of A Car Crash Only To Find His Fiancee Dead In The Wreckage
- DAILY INSPIRATION FOR POSITIVE LIVING
- NWPL Super 4: Okon says Lagos is fertile ground for Rivers Angels
- Top 10 players to look out for in the 2018 NWPL Super 4
- Messi hungry for more after reaching 400 La Liga goals
- Cristiano Ronaldo: Kathryn Mayorga lawyer to meet Jasmine Lennard
- SAR operatives get PDP gov. into trouble
- NFF sympathises with Kanu, calls on police to track down burglars
- CJN Onnoghen Saga: FG Asks NFIU To Freeze His Accounts
- Mba returns as Force spokesperson
- Nigeria has a date with destiny in 2019 – Saraki
- Onnoghen: Osinbajo says Buhari knew about CJN trial Saturday
- Ex-NAF chief forfeits billions to FG